Skip to main content
Hot Honey & Goat Cheese

Pizza in Portsmouth

Savory toppings and seasoned crusts feature on pizza at Oddfellows in Portsmouth, with pickup available for your next meal.

Order online

Popular Pizza to Try

The Hogfather

$16.00

Pizza with pepperoni, bacon, sausage, mozzarella, and garlic-butter crust.

Hot Honey & Goat Cheese

$17.00

Pepperoni pizza with mozzarella, goat cheese, arugula, and hot honey.

Cheesy Mediterranean

At the Heart of Oddfellows

At Oddfellows, pizza toppings include house gyro meat with feta and tzatziki, lion’s mane mushrooms with red pepper crema and ricotta, and creamy mac and cheese with bacon and blistered tomatoes.

Margherita pairs fresh mozzarella and basil with an olive oil crust. The Reuben has corned beef, sauerkraut and Swiss cheese; The Hogfather combines pepperoni, bacon and sausage on a garlic butter crust.

Visit Oddfellows in Portsmouth for dine-in, pickup or delivery. With Build Your Own Pizza, you can pair pepperoni and red onion, then add goat cheese or roasted garlic from the topping options.

Pizza to Try

“The vibe here is unlike anywhere else in Portsmouth. Very spacious with unique artwork, special to the area. We love to come here for brunch. There is also duck pin bowling, and outside seating if that’s something you’re interested in. JAMES is the BEST bartender - not only does he serve up great drinks, but his personality is spectacular. I love to get the pork belly bites, crabby benny or a Margherita pizza. Yum!”

“Fantastic food and service! The pizzas, wings, and vegetable appetizers were incredible and the atmosphere brought it all together! Our waiter James was attentive and accommodating. All around great experience!”

“I love the potato boats without the pork belly, and usually make my own pizza with mornay sauce, black olives, spinach, onions and garlic. Absolutely delicious!”

“The pizza at Oddfellows is amazing! The dough is obviously handmade and excellent and they use lots of high quality toppings. Wonderful location and always delicious food. Lots of vegetarian options and ability to customize your pizza. We’ve been eating here since opening but had our best experience there today. Our server was Brad and he is the best! Highly attentive, helpful and friendly.”

“Had a great dinner on Friday when some family was in town. Not first time I've been to Oddfellows by any means, though. Always enjoy to unique aspects of their menu along with awesome environment/building. Pretzel was great alongside the crispy wings and pizza. Also, the Oddball drink was delicious, though I had to change it up to their craft beer menu after one (wanted to make sure I could function the next day! 😀😀). Thanks!”

Cluck Norris

$16.00

Pizza with smoked chicken, buffalo sauce, blue cheese, and scallions.

“I love coming here for the delicious food and a few drinks after! James is genuinely the exception. He was so friendly and outstanding that it made my entire experience. The decor, hospitality, and vibes were so fantastic! They have different events every night which keeps the vibes alive as well as an extensive menu, from savory salmon and delicious mussels to a wide variety of pizzas.”

Kids Mac Pizza

$6.00

Pizza topped with macaroni and cheese, with a side selection.

“I recently discovered Oddfellows and I’m glad I did. I was impressed with the atmosphere and the quality of the food. Staff were friendly, and the service was great. The pizza is phenomenal. It’s wood fired and full of flavor. The salads look like works of art and taste just as good. I haven’t played any of the games yet, but they look fun as well. It reminds you of something you would find in a much larger city, but it’s right here in Portsmouth, Ohio. I highly recommend you try it. You will like it too.”

Mac Daddy

$16.00

Mac and cheese, bacon, cheddar, tomatoes, and scallions top this pizza.

“I went to odd fellows feeling down in life. Sometimes when things get dark, pizza is one of the only things that makes me smile. But that was before I met the hometown hero James. He made me smile bigger than I have in years. Combo that with the amazing pizza and it was an experience that could bring a mummy back to life. I highly recommend this place, it’s a breath of fresh air in Portsmouth!”

Frequently asked questions

What are your most popular pizza options?

Our guests love these customer favorites. If you're visiting us these are some of the food options we recommend most often.

  • The Hogfather — This pizza layers pepperoni, bacon, sausage, and mozzarella over a garlic-butter crust; optional toppings can be added.
  • Margherita — Classic sauce, fresh mozzarella, basil, and olive oil top a regular-crust pizza; chicken, ham, pepperoni, or sausage can be added.
  • Hot Honey & Goat Cheese — This pizza layers pepperoni and mozzarella with goat cheese, arugula, and a drizzle of hot honey for sweet heat.
  • Build Your Own Pizza — Choose regular or cauliflower crust, then select two regular toppings; gourmet toppings are optional add-ons.
  • The Cozy Pierogi — Regular crust is used, with up to three toppings available to customize this wood-fired pizza.

Do you offer delivery and takeout?

Yes! We offer both delivery and takeout for pizza throughout the Portsmouth area. Order your pizza online for convenient pickup or delivery.

Is there a kids menu?

Oddfellows offers kid-friendly options, including Kids Cheese Pizza and Kids Grilled Cheese.

Explore our menu to see all the options for your next family meal.