About Oddfellows
Our Story
“A story of love, resilience, and community– built from the dreams and passions of those behind it.”
Welcome to Oddfellows— the newest and quirkiest spot on the Boneyfiddle Historic block! Oddfellows is more than just a restaurant—it’s a story of love, resilience, and community, built from the dreams and passions of those behind it.
The journey began with Jeremy and Maddie, a couple who shared a vision to create something special in downtown Portsmouth. They envisioned Oddfellows as a unique space where people could come together for great food, fun, and community. A year into the building renovations, life took a difficult turn when Jeremy was diagnosed with a rare form of brain cancer. Their dreams were temporarily put on hold, but the renovations continued. Maddie’s father, Bob Rutman, stepped in and saw the first-floor renovations through to completion.
In June 2022, after a courageous battle, Jeremy passed away. His vision for Oddfellows could have ended there, but Maddie made it her mission to see Jeremy’s dream come to life and carry on his legacy. Oddfellows became a tribute to his spirit and the love they shared.
As the project continued, life had more in store for Maddie. She met Jay Kehoe, a builder, carpenter, and chef, whose skills and heart became vital to Oddfellows’ completion. As they built the restaurant together, they also fell in love, adding a new chapter to the Oddfellows story.
Oddfellows’ path wasn’t what anyone initially planned, but as the saying goes, “If you want to make God laugh, tell Him your plans.” The twists and turns have only made Oddfellows stronger, and today it stands as a symbol of love, community, and perseverance.
Our restaurant offers a unique atmosphere with handcrafted finishes made from reclaimed lumber from the very building. We pride ourselves on fresh, seasonal dishes and our signature wood-fired pizzas and chicken wings, crafted in custom-tiled ovens. More than just a place to eat, Oddfellows is a place to play, with duckpin bowling lanes and arcade games for all ages.
We invite you to come experience Oddfellows—a place built on love, resilience, and community. Whether it’s date night, family night, or just an evening out, Oddfellows is where you’ll find great food, fun, and connection.
-Maddie Burnside and Jay Kehoe, Owners
